Everything you always wanted to know about FSMA but were afraid to ask

The FDA’s revised Food Safety Modernization Act (FSMA) establishes “…science-based minimum standards for the safe growing, harvesting, packing, and holding fruits and vegetables grown for human consumption.”

While FSMA has meaningful implications for food safety regulations, it does not apply to every farm in the U.S. This document provides a brief overview of the produce categories covered by FSMA and the act’s exemptions.  If you are more visually oriented, take a look at the super intuitive flow chart at the bottom of the page, which will tell you right away whether you have to abide by FSMA or not.

Both the flow chart and the information below were put together by our policy intern, Clare Healy.

The six produce-related categories of FSMA application are as follows:

  1. Agricultural Water: Water Quality and Testing. Certain water used with growing and harvesting must be tested for the average amount and variability of E coli. Testing requirements vary based on type of water used (i.e. ground water, surface water, municipal water).
  2. Biological Soil Amendments: Raw Manure and Stabilized Compost. There must be a 120 day interval between the application of raw manure to soil and crops that will contact that soil, and a 90 day interval for crops that will not contact the soil.  Stabilized compost must be applied in a form that minimizes the risk of contact with crops before or after application.
  3. Sprouts: Irrigation water must be tested for certain pathogens, and pathogen tests must be negative before sprouts enter the marketplace. The growing, harvesting, packing and holding environment of sprouts must be tested for Listeria or Listeria monocytogenes.
  4. Domestic and Wild Animals: All farms must visually examine crops and fields/growing areas for contamination by animals. If significant contamination is found the area should be clearly marked, and crops may need to be forfeited.
  5. Worker Training and Health and Hygiene: Supervisors and farm workers handling produce and/or food-contact surfaces must be trained in proper hygiene practices, and implement hygienic practices, like hand and food-surface washing. Those who are ill or have a contagious infection should not have contact with farm’s produce or food-contact surfaces.
  1. Equipment, Tools and Buildings: There must be appropriate, secure, and clean storage of farm tools that come into contact with produce, as well as maintenance and cleanliness of other equipment.


FSMA Does not apply to:

  1. Fruits, vegetables, and grains that are not raw commodities, or that are rarely consumed raw. A complete list of “rarely consumed raw” foods can be found on pages 4-5 of Key Requirements: Final Rule on Produce Safety, cited at the end of this document.
  1. Produce consumed on-farm or as personal farm consumption.
  1. Farms that within the past three-year period from FSMA implementation have an average annual value of produce sold amounting to equal or less than $25,000.

In order to be eligible for qualified exemption, without meeting the exemptions above, a farm must meet the following two requirements:

  1. During the previous three-year period the farm’s average food sales must be less than $500,000; and
  2. During the previous three-year period the farm’s sales to “qualified end-users”—consumers and/or restaurant or retail food establishment located in the same state or Indian reservation as the farm, or no further than 275 miles away, must be greater than sales to all other markets combined.

For more information, including list of “Rarely Consumed Raw” crops, FSMA compliance dates, details on qualified exemptions, variances, and more, please see Key Requirements: Final Rule on Produce Safety.

this super intuitive flow chart









PCFA Nominated for Common Ground Award

We do the policy work we do for the sake of making change, but it’s also nice to get recognized every once in a while.  For that reason, we were honored to learn that we were nominated for not one, but two “Common Ground” awards.  Put together by the Metropolitan Pima Alliance, “Common Ground recognizes community leaders, projects and events with successful collaboration for the overall benefit of the community.”

The two projects were are being recognized for are:

  1. The advocacy we did around urban agriculture, which eventually led to the successful passing of an updated zoning code that is garden, farm, and urban ag-friendly.
  2. The advocacy we did around school gardening, which led to the State Health Department making their school garden guidelines more friendly towards the use of compost, rainwater, and other things.

After making the final round, we were asked to present to the selection committee, which we did last Thursday, July 28.  To be nominated and get to present in the final round alone is an honor; hopefully one of our projects wins an award!

HB 2518 Passes!

We spent much of the early part of 2016 doing advocacy on House Bill 2518 (see page 4, line 11), which sought to make school garden food automatically approved for use in the cafeteria.  We’re happy to announce that the bill was passed, and signed by the governor!  Thanks to those of you who responded to our calls (via facebook and e-blast) to call your representatives and ask for its passage.

The Turkey Police Are Coming

Disturbing developments are afoot with regarding to urban agriculture. After all the hard work we’ve done to get this to mayor and council, there is yet again a small group of people trying to make it appear there is widespread opposition to the proposed changes.

Where have those voices been all along? They claim they have been “bullied” into submission, which is patently false, as there’s been many opportunities for public input, and ample invitation from City Staff to comment. In this last ditch effort, their big goal is to reduce the number of animals allowed, and they’ve got the ear of at least one City Councilor, in Ward 6.

Can you help us one last time?? Here’s how:

  1. Send an email or make a phone call to the ward councilors and/or mayor with your comments. Ward member info is here. A sample letter for you to sign is here.
  2. Show up at the meeting and express your support for allowing more urban agriculture, specifically the right to have 24, 36, or, on really huge lots, 48 chickens. More info on how the animal units would work is here. Meeting info is below.
  3. Show up at the meeting, and simply wear one of our awesome chicken buttons.  Limited edition buttons in a new color will be available!  (See here.)
  4. Share this blog post on Facebook or with specific friends, asking them to take action.

Urban Ag Meeting Details
Tuesday December 8, at 6pm
255 W. Alameda St.
Council Chambers